Da Beers!

Da Beers!

Friday, January 31, 2014

Renewable Energy Could Generate $4 Billion to Aid in Salton Sea Restoration

The Imperial Irrigation District (IID) has released the “Salton Sea Revenue Potential Study” which estimates that development of renewable energy in the Salton Sea area could generated $4 billion in revenues for Salton Sea restoration over a 30 year period. The study considered revenue potential from development of geothermal, solar and biofuels, as well as other revenue sources. Geothermal development alone could produce two gigawatts of power.

The once vibrant Salton Sea ecosystem is under increasing stress from a number of factors, including water transfers to costal California. State and local governments are committed to restoring the Sea, but have yet to identify a feasible funding source. The Salton Sea Authority, a joint governmental agency that includes IID, is currently undertaking a feasibility and funding study in conjunction the State of California to determine potential revenue streams. The Authority is in discussions with the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) to review and augment the IID study using NREL expertise in long term development and marketing of renewables in the western United States. NREL recently concluded its own study entitled “Beyond Renewable Portfolio Standards: An Assessment of Regional Supply and Demand Conditions Affecting the Future of Renewable Energy in the West.” 


SaltonSea 







Sunday, January 26, 2014

Eucalyptus: Beauty or Beast?

Over at High Country News J. Madeleine Nash has posted an interesting piece on California's non-native Eucalyptus population, and focused on the well-known Blue Gum groves of  Montaña de Oro State Park near Morro Bay.

On one side of the controversy are folks who identify themselves as environmentalists, and who want to remove such non-natives to restore our badly disrupted native ecosystem.  These folks also worry about the pervasive spread of such exotics, and the increased fire hazard they create.

On the other side of the controversy are folks who also identify themselves as environmentalists, and who view these exotic trees as having just as much right to exist as indigenous Redwoods, Sequoias, or Oaks.  Apparently in their view all trees are equally wonderful, and equally huggable.

The money quote comes from environmental historian Jared Farmer, author of "Trees in Paradise: A California History."  Farmer says many see in these immigrant trees an experience that parallels their own.
"There are still a significant number of Californians who are the first generation in the state. They have come to love California. They have come to think of it as home. And they feel this kinship with the eucalyptus. They say to themselves, 'This tree is not from here, but it's beautiful, and it seems to fit'."
Just as these folks can't -- or won't -- see the damage such invasive plants do, neither do they choose to recognize the damage their own presence does here in California.

Our biggest problem isn't the divide between those who do and don't love California.  Our problem is the far too many people who love California so much that they feel they have a need -- and right -- to pile in here to live.  And with them came crowded roads and beaches, relentless habitat destruction, pervasive air and water pollution, and breathtaking increases in the cost of living that have driven many natives far inland, or completely out of the state.

But I suppose that's a massive problem -- a problem of the masses if you will -- that only us pre-1970s California Natives can truly appreciate.

Thursday, January 9, 2014

Wind Project "Take" Permits Extended To 30 Years - Eagles Nonplussed

J. Wylie Donald with McCarter & English notes that starting today, Bald and Golden Eagles will sleep less soundly.

 On 8 January 2014 the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s new rule revising the regulations for permits for the taking of golden eagles and bald eagles goes into effect. According to the FWS, “This change will facilitate the responsible development of renewable energy and other projects designed to operate for decades, while continuing to protect eagles consistent with our statutory mandates.”

Eagles and other migratory birds are a substantial threat to wind projects.  But not because they will cause turbine blades to fail. Rather, turbine blades (and to a lesser extent, towers, guy wires, transmission lines and other constructions in the air space) can be lethal to birds. This poses a serious problem for wind energy companies as birds are legally protected by the Migratory Bird Treaty Act (16 U.S.C. §§ 703-712), and eagles further protected by the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act (16 USC §§ 668-668d).

Duke Energy Renewables, Inc. recently ran afoul of these requirements at its 176 turbine Campbell Hill and Top of the World wind projects in Wyoming, where at least 14 golden eagles died between 2009 and 2013. In November, Duke accepted a plea agreement in “the first ever criminal enforcement of the Migratory Bird Treaty Act for unpermitted avian takings at wind projects.” It included:
  • Fines - $400,000
  • Restitution - $100,000 to the State of Wyoming
  • Community Service - $160,000 payment to the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation for eagle preservation projects
  • Conservation funding - $340,000 to a conservation fund for the purchase of land or conservation easements
  • Probation – five years
  • Compliance Plan – implementation of a plan at a cost of $600,000 per year with “specific measures to avoid and minimize golden eagle and other avian wildlife mortalities at company’s four commercial wind projects in Wyoming.”
  • Permit – required application for a Programmatic Eagle Take Permit.
That last item is directly tied to tomorrow’s rule. “Take” is defined in the regulations as “pursue, shoot, shoot at, poison, wound, kill, capture, trap, collect, destroy, molest, or disturb.” 50 CFR § 22.3. “Programmatic take” is “take that is recurring, is not caused solely by indirect effects, and that occurs over the long term or in a location or locations that cannot be specifically identified.” Id. The regulations at 50 CFR § 22.26 provide for permits to take bald eagles and golden eagles when the taking is associated with, but not the purpose of, an otherwise lawful activity. Programmatic permits authorize take that “is unavoidable even though advanced conservation practices are being implemented.” The new rule commentary notes that permits may authorize “lethal take … such as mortalities caused by collisions with wind turbines, powerline electrocutions, and other potential sources of incidental take.”

Under the current rule, a take permit was good for only 5 years, which inserted much uncertainty into wind farm projects. The new rule permits wind energy developers to obtain a take permit that runs for 30 years, 50 CFR § 22.26(i), which “better correspond[s] to the operational timeframe of renewable energy projects.” The risk that a wind project will cause unforeseen harm to eagles during this much longer period is mitigated by a new requirement for 5 year reviews, in which the FWS “will determine if trigger points specified in the permit have been reached that would indicate that additional conservation measures ... should be implemented to potentially reduce eagle mortalities, or if additional mitigation measures are needed.” Id. at § 22.26(h). Additional actions that might be taken as the result of the review could be permit changes, including implementation of additional conservation measures and updating of monitoring requirements. Id. Even suspension or revocation of the permit is possible. Id.

That the FWS is serious about protecting eagles is demonstrated by the enforcement action against entities like Duke (or against individuals like San Diego's own Dave Bittner). But the FWS also recognizes that development is necessary.  Given that tension Mr. Donald argues that the 30 year permit period appears to be a reasonable compromise (unless one is an eagle).

Thursday, January 2, 2014

Ramona's Amazing Pamo Valley

Having been raised in San Diego County's back country, I was pretty surprised when reading accounts of this year's Escondido (California) Christmas Bird Count to learn about a place I'd never heard of before: Pamo Valley.

The excitement for the centered around reports of multiple Lewis's Woodpeckers -- possibly as many as 8 or 10.  That's pretty remarkable for a bird that according to the SD Bird Atlas (Unitt) has only been reported on three of 17 Escondido (California) Christmas Bird Counts (1986 to 2001).

Adding to the allure of Pamo Valley were additional reports of multiple Golden Eagles, many Lark Sparrows, and Western Bluebirds together with Mountain Bluebirds which the Atlas describes as "highly irregular in southern California, usually localized and uncommon").  Once we'd heard all that, it wasn't tough to replace Ramona Grasslands on our 3d Annual New Year's Day Surf-to-Sand Cross-County Bird Trek.

Based on comments from other folks we ran into on New Year's Day, we aren't the only local birders who weren't aware of Pamo Valley.  So what's the story with this fantastic place?

According to a 2011 story in the Manchester Dis-United, most of the valley bottom is owned by the City of San Diego public utilities department’s enterprise water fund.  The city acquired the land in the 1950s as a reservoir site.  Uh oh.

While there are no plans to build a reservoir here now, the story notes that "there are no other good reservoir sites left in San Diego County."  Meanwhile, the city leases the land to a Ramona rancher who caretakes the 3,769 acres while grazing cattle.

The word “Pamo” probably comes from the Diegueno word, “paamuu,” according to “California Place Names” by Erwin G. Gudde and William Bright and citing an Indian rancheria called Pamo in Spanish records as early as 1778.  

The name was later adopted by Rancho Valle de Pamo (also called Rancho Santa María), a 17,709-acre grant given in 1843 by Governor Manuel Micheltorena to José Joaquín Ortega and Edward Stokes.  The grant occupied the Santa Maria Valley and was centered on present-day Ramona.  

With the cession of California to the United States following the Mexican–American War, the 1848 Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo provided that such land grants would be honored.  As required by the Land Act of 1851, a claim for Rancho Valle de Pamo was filed with the Public Land Commission and the grant was patented to José Joaquín Ortega and Eduardo Stokes in 1872.



Larger Image
UC Berkeley, Bancroft Library
   
The land changed hands several more times until it was acquired in 1886 by Milton Santee, a Los Angeles civil engineer and land developer. Santee started the Santa Maria Land and Water Company and subdivided what is now the townsite of Ramona.  Thankfully, Pamo Valley was too far off the beaten path to become a target for development.
Pamo Valley is surrounded by 4,052-foot-high Black Mountain to the east, 4,221-foot-high Pine Mountain to the north and Orosco Ridge to the west.  Both Santa Ysabel Creek and Temescal Creek run through the valley, the former being a tributary of the San Dieguito River that runs from Volcan Mountain near Julian to the ocean near Del Mar. Temescal Creek flows into the San Luis Rey River.

Tuesday, December 24, 2013

California Energy Commission says no to desert solar plant that could kill birds

Turns out it's not just wind turbines that kill birds. 

The High Country News Goat Blog reports on the threat to birds from high-intensity solar power arrays.

Saturday, December 14, 2013

"Birdorable" Birds

Apparently aimed at the brain-dead birder, here you go.

Don't say you weren't warned.

.

Tuesday, December 10, 2013

Do Bird Song Phone Apps and Other Recorded Playbacks Harm Birds?

The "harmful misuse" of mobile phone apps that mimic birdsong can stop birds performing important tasks such as feeding their young, experts have told the BBC.

Concerned about visitors using bird-call apps to entice seldom-seen species before their cameras, Dorset Wildlife Trust is also asking people to stop using the technology on all of its 42 reserves, arguing that it distracts birds from nesting and tending their young.

Tony Whitehead, from the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB), has also urged people to consider the consequences of their actions, saying:
Repeatedly playing a recording of birdsong or calls to encourage a bird to respond in order to see it or photograph it can divert a territorial bird from other important duties, such as feeding its young. It is selfish and shows no respect to the bird.
Clearly, this is a difficult and enduring problem. Local San Diego birders may recall a discussion on the subject on the old SDBirds listserv in September 2012 that quickly turned heated, and in which the best arguments presented in favor of using sound recordings in the field was, "I want to, so I will!" So very American.

So what's the objective ground truth?  Well, it depends who you listen to.  But there's an excellent and thoughtful piece on the subject at Sibley Guides online that seems to provide a useful starting place.

Noting that most claims for and against use of recordings are speculative and lacking in substantive research, Sibley offers these recommendations:

Respect for the Birds
  • Plan carefully and understand your quarry so that you can guess where the bird is, or where it is likely to be. If you have already heard it or seen it, consider those locations when deciding where to play audio. You must be in (or very near) the bird’s territory to get a useful response.
  •  
  • Choose your spot and set the stage – Visualize the scenario of the bird coming into view. How will it approach the recording, and where will it sit so that you can see it? You should play the recording from a location that offers the bird a comfortable approach through its preferred habitat, and also has openings, edges, and/or prominent perches where it will come into view. Many playback efforts are unsuccessful either because the bird will not cross unsuitable habitat, or because dense vegetation allows it to approach closely while remaining hidden.
  •  
  • Begin by playing the recording quietly for just a few seconds – for example just two or three songs, then stop, watch, and listen.
  •  
  • Use short snippets – If there is any response, try very short snippets of song after that, even stopping the recording after half of a normal song, to try to tease the bird into the open without posing a serious challenge to its self-esteem.
  •  
  • Watch for a response – If there is no obvious response after 30-60 seconds, play another 15-30 seconds of sound. Remember that the bird may respond by approaching silently, or by guarding its mate, so a lack of song is not necessarily a lack of response, and you can assume that you are being watched. Watch the vegetation carefully on all sides for an approach, and also watch and listen for a response from neighboring males.
  •  
  • Remain calm – If you still don’t detect any response, play the recording again, watch and wait, and repeat. But don’t keep this up longer than about five minutes, and resist the urge to finish with a prolonged, loud barrage of song.
  •  
  • Check back later – Many birds will remain silent in the immediate aftermath of the playback, and then begin singing vigorously minutes later. Males in other territories might monitor the playback, and the challenge to their neighbor, and also be stimulated to sing minutes later. If you can wait around, or circle back to check on the area after 10 to 30 minutes, you may find that the desired response to playback is occurring then.
  •  
Respect for ones fellow birders
  • Be courteous – Before starting, ask your fellow birders if anyone objects to using playback.
  •  
  • Don’t surprise people – Before each burst of playback, announce to the group that you are about to start playback (just quietly saying “playback” will do), and hold the device up above your head during playback so other birders can see at a glance the source of the sound.
  •  
  • Be unobtrusive – Keep the volume low and play only short clips of sound – 30 seconds or less – then pause to watch and listen for a response.

Wednesday, December 4, 2013

My Most Miserable Months: Life As a Palomar Audubon Society Board Member

Between March 2013 and September 2013, I did my best to serve as an elected Director on the Board of Palomar Audubon Society, a non-profit charitable corporation headquartered in Escondido, California.

When I finally threw in the towel and gave up trying to help people who clearly didn't want to be helped, I resolved to adopt a "live and let live" approach towards those usually-genial but sorely misguided people.  However, since I've learned these folks are still dragging my name through the mud, I feel the need to set the record straight.

* * *

To make a very long story short, I did my best to avoid getting involved with the corporate governance of this operation.  As an attorney at law, I know too well the perils of trying to run a non-profit corporation alongside folks who don't share my professional background and ethical responsibilities.

Nevertheless, after several years of social birding with Palomar Audubon, these folks kept pleading with me to get more involved by serving on their Board.

Sadly, however, after I relented and agreed to serve as a Palomar Audubon Society Director, I quickly learned that the folks who have been running Palomar Audubon Society for at least the past few years had precious little understanding of the seriousness involved in running any publicly chartered non-profit charitable corporation.

Among the problems I soon discovered were:
  • A complete lack of any kind of training or indoctrination program for new officers and directors (which probably goes a long, long ways towards explaining all the other serious problems I found at Palomar Audubon Society) 
  • A propensity to willfully ignore the provisions of the corporation's Articles of Incorporation and Bylaws on the ground that it is just too much hard work
  • Use of illegal email voting procedures for official board actions
  • Complete lack of Board editorial control or oversight of the Society's official newsletters and website
  • Failure to review and update the Society's Bylaws in over a decade as California non-profit corporation law and the federal tax code continued to change and evolve
  • Inability and/or unwillingness to read and follow the corporation's simple Bylaws with respect to quorum rules, term of office for Officers and Directors, number of Board and Member meetings required annually, and many other crucial aspects of corporate governance
  • Lack of proper notice for Board and Member meetings, and especially for the election by the Members of corporate Officers and Directors
  • Lack of any long-term plan for recruiting and filling Director, Officer, Committee Chair, and Committee vacancies
  • Public announcement of appointment of a new Conservation Committee Chair (arguably the most important non-elective position in this kind of conservation organization) without the required approval of the Board of Directors
  • An embarrassing lack of sophistication and understanding of what it actually means to "partner" with another non-profit or agency in the conservation field
  • An irrational desire on the part of some Board members to continue a donor relationship with the Wildlife Research Institute of Ramona (WRI) ... long after it was discovered that WRI director David Bittner had pled guilty to Federal crimes associated with the illegal taking of protected raptors
This is by no means an exhaustive list of problems evident at Palomar Audubon Society.  But it does provide a general flavor of the many problems I discovered during my brief time dealing with the "leaders" of that non-profit.

Fortunately, I subsequently found that my "election" was fatally flawed, and that I had therefore never actually been a legally constitued member of the Palomar Audubon Society Board of Directors.  Great relief that!

Due to the ugly things that were said and done during the course of my brief time trying to serve the Members of Palomar Audubon Society, we have also completely withdrawn from having anything to do with Palomar Audubon Society.  Which is actually quite sad, considering that up until this year -- and as lame as Palomar Audubon Society can be with respect to actual birding expertise -- Palomar Audubon Society had become a large part of our social life.

* * *

Otherwise, I wouldn't presume to tell anyone what to do with their charitable dollars.   However, I would recommend that before you donate significant funds to any non-profit, take the time to learn about the organization's management through research, and through direct observation of the non-profit's leadership at Board meetings and the like.

In addition, if you are ever approached to serve on the board of any non-profit, be very careful about who you're getting involved with.  Many non-profits are professionally managed and beyond reproach.  Others, however, are run with all the professionalism of a church bake sale.  Or of a numbers racket. 

Nor do the state Attorney's General tend to devote much in the way of resources to overseeing these ubiquitous organizations which have proliferated like fleas as unscrupulous individuals have come to recognize the naive generosity of many Americans who will unquestionably donate to anything or anyone labeled "non-profit."      

Done right, non-profit board service is also very demanding work ... albeit work that one can rightly take great pride in if done well.

In the worst case, as a non-profit director or officer you may find yourself being held personally liable for the transgressions of the non-profit, or of your fellow Directors or Officers.  

Bottom line:  Be careful out there!  As with many other aspects of life in this Brave New World, you're pretty much on your own nowadays.

Monday, November 18, 2013

Great New Birder Documentary

Devoting equal time and affection to birds and birders, first-time filmmaker Jeffrey Kimball adeptly explores humanity, nature and the precarious balance between the two in "BIRDERS: THE CENTRAL PARK EFFECT".

On the bird level, Kimball captures a remarkable number of species in Central Park with some stunning HD photography in this brief but amazing 58-minute film.

The film also introduces some truly devoted NYC birders, including a group of old-school birders with the obligatory photo cannons, brass-instrument technician Chuck McAlexander, and septuagenarian bird-tour leader Starr Saphir -- a true matriarch of Central Park birdwatching who, sadly, has sucumbed to cancer since the film was shot, and who was once memorialized by TV's Conan "Coco" O’Brien when he joined one of Starr's locally-famous field trips.

Kimball looks at Central Park birding in all four seasons. But as expected, Spring and Fall migration are his "stars" when hundreds of birders converge to take advantage of the "Central Park Effect" -- shorthand for the observed phenomenon that as the earth becomes more urbanized and developed, migrating birds increasingly seek out islands of nature like Central Park.

This is, in the end, an HD film, so Kimball spends a lot of time on striking birds like Indigo Buntings, Rose-breasted Grosbeaks, Hooded Warblers, and the like but. But as veteran birder Lloyd Spitalnik sagely notes, "If you get tired of looking at the common birds, you might as well just pack it in." Indeed.

Then there's birder Chris Cooper, who says his friends don't see him from April 15th through Memorial Day.  But if his friends question his annual obsession, Chris says he now counters by rattling off his "seven pleasures of birding":
  • The beauty of the birds
  • The beauty of being in a natural setting
  • The joys of hunting, without the bloodshed
  • The joy of collecting (in that the practice of keeping lists -- life lists, day lists, etc.-- appeals to the same impulse as, say, stamp collecting)
  • The joy of puzzle-solving (in making those tough identifications)
  • The pleasure of scientific discovery (new observations about behavior, etc.); and last but not least
  • The "Unicorn Effect," by which Cooper refers to the phenomenon familiar to most birders -- the idea that there are birds you've heard of, or seen in books that capture your imagination, but you've never seen for yourself ... then one day, there it is in front of you, as if some mythical creature has stepped out of a storybook and come to life.
The film also includes the obligatory interviews with "experts" like David Burg with WildMetro, Dr. John Fitzpatrick from the Cornell Lab of Ornithology, and John Flicker from National Audubon.   But it's the "regular" birders who are the most endearing here.

Is there a downside to this film?  Just that it further enshrines Jonathan Franzen as the public face of American birding -- an unfortunate extension of Franzen's novels and essays he’s written for The New Yorker about his birding activities.  Laura Helmuth's article at Slate.com does a good job of explaining what an embarrassment Franzen is to the rest of us birders.  Sure, birders are all a bit obsessive-compulsive, and quite a few birders are socially retarded.  But we don't need this untalented jerk out there scaring people away from birding with his self doubts and self-loathing, his guilt-tripping about time taken away from worthier pursuits, and so forth.

Thursday, September 12, 2013

Corrupt California State Parks system still needs work

According to a story in the LA Times, a new audit reveals that the California parks department, which was rocked by an accounting scandal last year, has not completely corrected its bad practices.   Assemblywoman Beth Gaines (R-Rocklin), who requested the audit, added that parks officials should be "moving faster."

The parks scandal broke last summer when it was revealed that the department had a surplus of $54 million at the same time the state was threatening to close parks because of a budget crisis. A subsequent investigation determined that roughly $20 million was deliberately hidden by parks officials.

Added Assemblywoman Gaines:  "California's state parks are among its most precious and beautiful resources. At the very least, they deserve reliable bookkeeping and quality leadership, neither of which they have right now."

What!?  Even with a Marine Corps "general" at the helm, the agency lacks "quality leadership"?!

Image of Major General Anthony L. Jackson
Actually, I worked for this "general" a few years back.  He wasn't much a leader then either.  Which is why I don't subscribe to this modern cult of American military exceptionalism.  In my experience, it's mainly misguided self-delusion, plus a whole lot of smoke and mirrors.